As researchers, it’s crucial to navigate this landscape with vigilance to ensure the integrity of academic work. So, grab your metaphorical magnifying glass, and let’s uncover the clues!

Spotting Hijacked or Mirroring Scopus-Indexed Journals: A Detective’s Guide

1. Assess the Journal’s Website

The first step in our investigation is to visit the journal’s website. Here are some red flags to watch out for:

• Contact Information: Legitimate journals provide clear contact details for their editorial offices. If you can’t find any contact information or it seems suspiciously vague, proceed with caution.
• Editorial Board: Reputable journals have an established editorial board comprising experts in the field. Check if the journal lists its editorial team. If it’s missing or consists of fictional characters (okay, maybe not that extreme, but you get the idea), raise your eyebrows.
• Website Security: Is the website secure? Look for the padlock icon in the address bar. If it’s missing, consider it a warning sign.

2. Investigate Publication Charges

Predatory journals often have a love affair with money. Here’s what to look for:

• Exorbitant Fees: Some shady journals charge exorbitant publication fees. If the cost seems unreasonable, it’s time to put on your detective hat.
• Peer Review Claims: Ask whether the journal conducts peer reviews. Legitimate journals take this seriously. If they’re vague about their review process or claim instant acceptance, be suspicious.

3. Search Aggregator Sites

Avoid Googling the journal directly. Instead, visit reputable aggregator sites (like Scopus itself) and search for the journal there. Why? Because hijacked journals often appear among the top results in regular search engines. Aggregators provide a safer entry point.

4. Cloned Websites: The Art of Deception

Hijacked journals often exist as “cloned” websites. These look eerily similar to legitimate journals but harbor subtle differences. Here’s what to watch for:

• Web Domain Tricks: The web domain might be slightly altered—maybe an extra letter, a different top-level domain, or a sneaky hyphen. These changes go unnoticed at first glance.
• Mismatched Content: Hijacked journals often publish unrelated content. For instance, an obstetrics and gynecology journal suddenly starts discussing prostate cancer or kidney diseases. That’s like a bakery selling car parts—something’s fishy!

5. Peer Inside Scopus Profiles

Scopus profiles are like the journal’s passport. Investigate them:

• Content Consistency: Compare the indexed papers in the original journal with those in the cloned version. If they’re indexed simultaneously, it’s like having twins with different birth certificates—unlikely and suspicious.
• Mismatched Specialization: If the cloned content doesn’t match the journal’s actual specialization, it’s a hijacking alert. Heart journals shouldn’t suddenly publish oral cancer therapies.

Conclusion: Stay Vigilant!

As researchers, we’re guardians of knowledge. By following these clues, we can protect ourselves from the murky waters of hijacked journals. Remember, a magnifying glass and a healthy dose of skepticism are your best allies. Happy sleuthing! 🕵️‍♂️🔍

And there you have it—a concise guide to spotting those elusive journal impostors! If you ever find yourself in a dark alley of dubious publications, just remember: Trust your instincts, verify the facts, and keep your academic compass pointing true north. 🌟

Sources:

1. Journal hijackers still infiltrate Scopus despite its efforts
2. How to find a predatory, cloned and hijacked Scopus journal
3. Hijacked-journal tracker helps researchers to spot scam websites
4. Hijacked journals vs predatory journals

Feel free to explore these sources for further insights! 😊📚

These are my personal steps and resources on checking hijacked/mirroring scopus indexed journals. Good luck!

• My Check
  • Scimagojr
    • Publisher’s link
    • ISSN
    • Comments
  • Suspected Journals Web site
  • ISSN
  • scopus database
    • Source
    • Compare indexed list with suspected journal
• Lists
  • Bealls list
  • Retraction Database (web)
  • Retraction Database (xls)
  • Doaj
• Others
  • email check
  • Google Scholar
  • Scopus Support
  • Journal Article

Perlunya RIS to CSV Converter

RIS to CSV converter penting dalam SLR. Terkait dengan structured Literature Review, download database sangat penting untuk dilakukan. Dalam melakukan structured Literature Review, kita memerlukan data-data yang terpercaya dan relevan. Salah satu sumber data yang dapat digunakan adalah database. Dalam melakukan structured Literature Review, database dapat membantu kita dalam mengumpulkan data-data yang relevan dengan topik yang sedang diteliti. Selain itu, database juga dapat membantu kita dalam melakukan analisis data dan menyusun kerangka pemikiran yang jelas.

Dalam melakukan download database pada structured Literature Review, ada beberapa hal yang perlu diperhatikan. Pertama, pastikan bahwa database yang digunakan terpercaya dan relevan dengan topik yang sedang diteliti. Kedua, pastikan bahwa data yang diunduh sudah sesuai dengan kebutuhan penelitian. Ketiga, pastikan bahwa data yang diunduh sudah dalam format yang mudah diolah.

Dalam melakukan structured Literature Review, kita dapat menggunakan beberapa database yang terpercaya seperti Scopus, Web of Science, dan Google Scholar. Selain itu, kita juga dapat menggunakan database yang disediakan oleh perpustakaan perguruan tinggi atau institusi penelitian.

Dalam melakukan download database pada structured Literature Review, kita dapat menggunakan beberapa teknik seperti Boolean search, citation search, dan reference chaining. Teknik-teknik ini dapat membantu kita dalam menemukan data-data yang relevan dengan topik yang sedang diteliti.

Dalam melakukan structured Literature Review, download database sangat penting untuk dilakukan. Dengan menggunakan database, kita dapat mengumpulkan data-data yang relevan dengan topik yang sedang diteliti dan menyusun kerangka pemikiran yang jelas. Oleh karena itu, pastikan bahwa download database dilakukan dengan baik dan benar.

Salah satu masalah yang sering dialami oleh peneliti yang melakukan SLR adalah download yang tidak lengkap jika dilakukan menggunakan format file CSV. Solusinya adalah melakukan proses download dalam format RIS dan kemudian melakukan konversi dari RIS ke CSV.

Berikut adalah link untuk melakukan proses konversi RIS ke CSV. RIS to CSV Converter.